Carpet Sweepers Vs Vacuum Cleaners : Which Is Better?

Having a hard time deciding between a vacuum cleaner and a sweeper for your carpet?

Well, we are here to clear your confusion and help you to make the right decision.

Now, though both sweepers and vacuums have similarities, they are very different.

In this carpets sweepers vs vacuum cleaners comparison guide, I’m going to pit them against each other and give you a detailed comparison between the two. 

So, keep reading on, and I can promise you that after reading this article, you’ll have a clear idea of which one to go with.

Let’s dive in.

Difference Between Carpet Sweepers and Vacuum Cleaners

Below we are going to compare both of them feature by a feature which will help you to make a decision between them.

  • Time Consideration

Indeed home is where our heart belongs, and in the modern world, the working class prefers small but efficient, and affordable homes. So if you are from a working-class community, surely you don’t want to spend most of your leisure time doing household chores.

The major point is to save time. In that case, the vacuum cleaner gets extra points since it takes less time to clean the dirt than a carpet sweeper. You just turn it on and roam it around the entire floor, and the job is done. Well, don't forget to dispose too!

On the other hand, it will take you a bit longer to clean the house with a carpet sweeper. So, if you are someone who is a bit short in time and want to clean things up as quickly as possible, it would be better for you to get a vacuum cleaner.

That said, the time difference isn’t really huge, and though you should consider this issue while choosing between them, it shouldn’t be the only deciding factor.

  • Physical Labor

A carpet sweeper is something that works only when you keep pushing it. So it requires human labor more, and after a day full of workloads, you may not always be up for such hard work. 

On the contrary, the vacuum will need to be roamed around, but it works on electricity, so you don't have to really push it hard. Just press the button and keep it moving.

So, unless you have a lot of stamina and the willingness to work hard for long periods, then perhaps vacuum cleaner might be the right option for you.

However, if you are ok with manual pushing of the device, then there’s no harm trying out the sweeper.

  • Noise

Since the vacuum cleaner works on motors and electricity, it makes an extreme sound which is annoying and may cause a headache. Also, the sound disturbs other people too.

So, if want to clean the house without disturbing the sleep of your spouse, then it might not be a good idea to purchase a vacuum cleaner.

On the other hand, sweepers do not make much noise. They work quietly.

This is the reason most of the restaurants tend to use carpet sweepers more to do their tiny cleaning jobs without bothering their customers.

So, if you are looking to conduct your cleaning process in silence, then I’d say that a carpet sweeper is the right option for you.

Nevertheless, you can find vacuum devices on the market that can work with minimum sound and won’t ruin your husband’s sleep. That said, they are often a bit expensive than regular vacuums.

Thus, if you have made your mind to use a vacuum machine, then buy one that goes about its business quietly.

  • Area Matters

Before choosing between them, you need to ask yourself how many square feets you are going to clean. The answer to that question will make the decision a lot easier for you.

For, when it comes to bigger areas like an entire room or floor, it is wiser and less time consuming to use vacuum cleaner. That’s because they can clean fast, and won’t take up much of your time. With good vacuums, you can clean a medium-sized room in minutes.

However, you must keep in mind that vacuums are unable to reach tight spaces in your house.

In order to clean the tiniest corner where the vacuum cannot reach, and to pick up the smallest cookie crumbs, you will need to use a carpet sweeper.

Because it is easier and quicker to use a sweeper rather than a vacuum which probably will not even reach the tiny areas.

  • Number of Piles

In the case of high-pile carpets, go for a vacuum since there is too much dirt to dispose. On the other hand, if there are low-pile carpets then the job can be done using carpet sweeper easily and swiftly.

  • Power Absorbance Capability

One major disadvantage of a vacuum cleaner is it consumes way too much power. So the electricity bill goes high, the more you keep using it. The manual carpet sweepers do not need electricity. That is how it saves your budget too.

So, if you intend to save some bucks, then a sweeper is a no-brainer. However, if you put comfort before money, then you will want to buy a vacuum for your house. 

  • Filters

Some vacuum cleaners come with “HEPA” filters that help to clean up the tiniest particles that the carpet sweeper misses. I would recommend such vacuums for people with allergy problems.

However, carpet sweepers do not come with any such filters. So, if you would like a HEPA filter for you, then there’s only one option left.

  • Varieties

An electric carpet sweeper is better than a manual sweeper since the brushes are always working even when you are not pushing. So it is easier to use. A vacuum cleaner always works on electricity, so there is no alternative method.

Wire-free technology is the most updated version of vacuum cleaners. Since in this technology, literally no string is attached, so it leaves room for flexibility. But it is not as powerful as the electric corded ones, but for the short time work, it is surely a convenient option.

  • Versatility and Cord Length

These two factors are very important while choosing your cleaner. For instance, some vacuum cleaners are better at specific works, while others use tools and filters that make them open to more variations.

Therefore, you would want to get a device that offers versatility and allows you to clean a lot of things. That way, you won’t have to buy a sperate cleaner for everything.

And when it comes to versatility, vacuum devices trump over the sweepers.

You also should take notice of the cord length of the device. The length of the cord matters. If it’s a long cord, then you can go about cleaning without worrying about where the power outlet is. Similarly, if it’s battery-driven, then the battery life needs to be considered.

  • Warranty

Warranty indicates the duration or quality of the cleaners. It varies product by product, but most of their shelf life is 1 to 5 years. The common ones come with a year warranty, but the one that gives a 5-year warranty is the best o pick according to me as it shows guarantee and more endurance.

Which One to Choose?

As you can see, both devices have their own advantages and shortcomings.

So, the ideal product will vary from person to person. Thus, it’s only possible for you to decide which one is best for you.

The safest option is to go for both. If you have such a budget then this is the perfect way to keep balance.

And if you are running short on cash and do not want to spend much on cleaning tools, then you better stick to the one that suits your home or work environment.


After all the discussion, it is time to conclude with a decision. I will reiterate that I think buying both an electric vacuum and the carpet sweeper will be the best solution for you.

But if you have to go for only one, I would suggest going for the electric vacuum cleaner which will serve most of your cleaning needs.

Nevertheless, let me know your thoughts in the comments section.

Click to Share
Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 1 comments